Amended
IN
Assembly
April 15, 2021 |
Introduced by Assembly Member Bonta (Coauthors: Assembly Members ( |
February 18, 2021 |
This bill would require the state to contract with one or more organizations to appoint members to a visitor and caller review committee, to be composed of specified individuals, and to provide a visitor and caller liaison in each facility overseen by the department that provides in-person video or video calling. The bill would require the liaison to ensure
that the rights of visitors and callers are protected during in-person and noncontact visiting and video calling at these facilities, and to be present in the visiting and video calling areas during visiting and video calling hours. The bill would require each facility overseen by the department to establish a visitor and caller review committee, consisting of specified persons, would make the committee responsible for reviewing complaints related to denied applications for visits or calling access, would require the committee to make a decision on the complaint within 20 days of the filing of that complaint, and would establish a review process for the committee’s decision.
At least once per year, this bill would require each incarcerated person to be given the opportunity to designate an individual as their primary support person. If an incarcerated person is not placed in a facility that is within 100 miles of their primary support person, the bill would require
that the primary support person and their minor children be given free transportation, transportation vouchers, or transportation reimbursement from an organization that contracts with the department to provide free or subsidized transportation for visits with incarcerated persons, as specified.
(a)A person shall have the right to an in-person contact visit with an incarcerated person.
(b)A visit may only be denied as follows:
(1)(A)The visitor has committed one or more of the following offenses in a prison or jail:
(i)They brought contraband into the facility during a visit. For purposes of this clause, contraband excludes any lawful amount of alcohol, marijuana, or other intoxicants for personal use in a vehicle parked on facility grounds.
(ii)(I)They engaged in sexual intercourse, penetration,
masturbation, or oral copulation during a visit with a person other than a family visit.
(II)For purposes of this subdivision, “masturbation” shall mean skin-to-skin contact with genitalia.
(iii)They committed violence during a visit or the visiting screening process.
(iv)They attempted, or aided in, an escape during a visit.
(B)A visitor who has committed an offense described under clause (i) to (iv), inclusive, of subparagraph (A) may be denied visits for up to one year after the commission of that offense.
(2)(A)The visitor has not provided a criminal history report, as issued by the Department of Justice, and government issued photographic identification
before approval of a visitor application. A visitor who fails to provide this information may be denied the right to visit until the required information is provided and the application is processed.
(B)For purposes of subparagraph (A), the criminal history report shall be obtainable by the prospective visitor free of charge.
(3)The incarcerated person freely withholds consent to the visit. The incarcerated person shall not be required to withhold consent to a visit as a disciplinary sanction, as a means of avoiding a disciplinary sanction, or as a condition of participating in programming or enjoying any privilege while incarcerated.
(c)A visit shall not be denied for any of, but not limited to, the following reasons:
(1)As a disciplinary sanction against the incarcerated person that is not based on any violation of a law or regulation by the incarcerated person that occurred during the incarcerated person’s visit with the affected visitor.
(2)Solely due to the incarcerated person’s restricted housing status, including placement in administrative segregation or a security housing unit.
(3)Due to an omission or inaccuracy on the visitor application if the omitted or correct information is provided on the visitor’s criminal history report, as issued by the Department of Justice.
(4)Because of a visitor’s criminal, juvenile delinquency, or other history of involvement with law enforcement, whether or not it resulted in a criminal conviction, other than a conviction for an offense listed in paragraph (1) of subdivision (b), a visitor’s current status of being under parole, postrelease community supervision,
probation, or informal probation supervision, or a visitor’s previous incarceration, including incarceration in the facility where the visit will take place.
(5)Due to the nature of the incarcerated person’s criminal, juvenile delinquency, or other history of involvement with law enforcement, regardless of whether it resulted in a criminal conviction, other than a conviction for an offense set forth under clause (i) to (iv), inclusive, of subparagraph (A) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (b), except when required by Section 1202.05.
(d)To the extent that visiting rules and standards, as prescribed in Title 15 of the California Code of Regulations, conflict with this section, the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation shall adopt regulations that conform with this section.
(b)Phone and video calls shall be provided free of charge to the incarcerated person and the caller.
(c)In-person contact and noncontact visits shall not be limited in
duration within the visiting hours.
(d)A cell phone or tablet that is capable of voice over internet protocol shall be provided free of charge to each incarcerated person. This phone or tablet shall have the ability to send and receive calls and emails while the incarcerated person is in their housing area. The incarcerated person shall have the right, when not engaged in programming or a work assignment, to send and receive calls and emails to and from a preapproved list of personal correspondents, an attorney, court, legal library, or legal services organization.
(e)
(1)Whenever the incarcerated person has been hospitalized or moved to a medical unit of the facility.
(f)
(g)Whenever in-person
visiting is impossible, all previously scheduled in-person visiting time shall be replaced by additional video calling time that is free of charge to the incarcerated person and the caller.
(h)To the extent that visiting rules and standards, as prescribed in Title 15 of the California Code of Regulations, conflict with this section, the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation shall adopt regulations that conform with this section.
(a)A nonuniformed social worker, who is chosen and trained by the visitor and caller liaison, as specified in Section 6403, shall be readily available during visiting hours, and shall be responsible for screening minors before any visit. The screening of a minor shall not be conducted by a correctional officer unless the parent, or the minor who is 13 years of age or older, consents.
(b)A licensed health care provider shall be readily available during visiting hours, and shall be responsible for conducting unclothed body searches. An unclothed body search shall be conducted in a private location. An unclothed body search shall not be conducted by a correctional
officer unless the visitor consents.
(c)A search of clothing and personal property shall be conducted in the presence of the visitor, and, if requested by the visitor, shall be video recorded.
(d)A prison employee shall only enforce visiting rules and standards prescribed in law, including this code and Title 15 of the California Code of Regulations.
(e)A visit may be terminated only if the visitor engages in any of the following during the visit:
(1)Fails to provide a valid government-issued photo identification at the time of the visit for each adult visitor, emancipated minor visitor, and minor who is a spouse of the incarcerated person whom the
minor seeks to visit, or fails to provide valid documentation of a change of name or address from that information supplied on the visitor’s application. Valid documentation includes, but is not limited to, marriage or divorce court documents, a lease or deed, an item of mail delivered to the new address, and a temporary driver’s license or permit.
(2)Fails to provide documentation establishing that an adult accompanying a minor not described in paragraph (1) is the minor’s parent or legal guardian or has permission from the minor’s parent or legal guardian to visit the incarcerated person whom the minor seeks to visit.
(3)Notwithstanding paragraphs (1) and (2), inclusive, prison employees may waive identification and documentation requirements.
(4)Wears clothing that resembles the clothing of people incarcerated or employed at the facility and refuses to change into different clothing.
(5)(A)Wears clothing that does not cover most of the front and back torso, thighs, and breasts, or does not completely cover the buttocks, genitalia, and areola.
(B)Wears clothing described in subparagraph (A) and refuses to change into different clothing.
(6)Disrupts the visiting area, fails to follow staff instructions, or engages in sexual conduct, as defined in subdivision (f), other than in a family visit, after the visitor has been counseled to stop and warned that continuing the
behavior could lead to termination of the visit.
(7)Refuses to submit to a search as authorized under this section.
(8)Commits any of the offenses listed in subparagraph (A) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (b) of Section 6401.
(f)(1)For purposes of this section, “sexual conduct” means either of the following:
(A)The rubbing or touching of any breast, buttock, or sexual organ for the purpose of arousing, appealing to, or gratifying lust, passions, or sexual desires.
(B)The exposure of any breast, buttock, or sexual organ for the purpose of arousing, appealing to, or
gratifying lust, passions, or sexual desires.
(2)For purposes of this section, sexual conduct excludes any acts addressed under subparagraphs (A) to (D), inclusive, and the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation shall not prohibit those acts.
(A)Holding hands or touching the head, back, shoulders, or lower thighs.
(B)For a child who is 12 years of age or younger, sitting on an adult’s lap.
(C)Hugging or kissing at the beginning or end of a visit.
(D)Hugging or kissing at any time with a child who is 12 years of age or younger.
(g)Security and administrative tasks, including computer upgrades, shall be scheduled at a time that does not interfere with visiting or when there is additional staff available to perform those tasks to ensure the tasks do not interfere with visiting. Whenever facility visiting hours are canceled or reduced due to a genuine emergency, the facility shall provide accommodations for visitors who show up for visits on that day, and these accommodations shall continue until visits are again made available. Additional visiting hours shall be scheduled within 24 hours of the termination of visits due to the emergency if necessary to accommodate the visitors.
(h)If a visit or call is interrupted or terminated, and the warden or a court later determines there was no cause for the interruption or termination, the facility shall
provide the visitor or caller with additional visiting and calling time, and shall reimburse the visitor or caller for any expenses associated with the interrupted or terminated call.
(i)To the extent that visiting rules and standards, as prescribed in Title 15 of the California Code of Regulations, conflict with this section, the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation shall adopt regulations that conform with this section.
(a)(1)The state shall contract with one or more organizations, as described in paragraph (2), to appoint members of a visitor and caller review committee and to provide a visitor and caller liaison in each facility overseen by the department that provides in-person visiting or video calling. The contract shall not be terminated on the ground that one or more of the liaisons zealously advocates for the rights of visitors or callers.
(2)The organization shall be led by formerly convicted or incarcerated or system-impacted people, and shall have at least a five-year history of providing services to, or advocating for, those people independent of the
Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation. System-impacted refers people who have borne financial or other costs of having relationships with currently or formerly convicted or incarcerated people.
(b)(1)The liaison shall ensure that the rights of visitors and callers are protected during all in-person contact and noncontact visiting and video calling at facilities overseen by the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation.
(2)The liaison shall be present in the visiting and video calling areas during all visiting and video calling hours, and shall be authorized to interact directly and promptly with staff in the visiting or video calling areas to raise concerns about compliance with laws and regulations on visiting and video calling.
(3)If unable to resolve a concern with staff, the liaison shall have the right to immediately contact the highest official on duty to raise the concern.
(4)If the concern is not resolved, the liaison or the affected visitor or caller may individually or collectively file a formal complaint, and the warden shall be required to resolve and respond to the complaint within three days. Once a complaint is made, surveillance video of the relevant visiting or calling area for the date and time of the alleged violation shall be preserved until the complaint and any subsequent legal proceeding are resolved.
(c)Each institution within the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation shall establish a visitor and caller review
committee consisting of an equal number of persons appointed by one or more organizations, as described in paragraph (2) of subdivision (a), and persons appointed by the warden. If an application for visiting or calling access is denied, or visiting or calling rights are suspended or revoked, and a complaint is filed, this committee shall meet to review the complaint and determine whether a violation of law or regulations occurred. The committee shall make a decision on the complaint within 20 days of the filing of the complaint. The committee’s decision, or the opinions of the committee members if the committee is not able to reach consensus, shall be reviewed by the warden, who shall make a final decision within 15 days of receiving the committee’s communication. The warden’s decision shall be reviewable by a superior court upon de novo review by petition for a writ of habeas corpus. The
visitor or caller shall have third-party standing to raise issues on behalf of the incarcerated person whose visit or call was affected. Upon request, the liaison shall assist people who have been denied visiting and calling access.
(d)A liaison, or the affected visitor or caller, may individually or collectively file a complaint for noncompliance of visiting rules and laws, including Section 6405, by way of a petition for a writ of habeas corpus filed in superior court, and that court shall make a decision upon de novo review. The visitor or caller shall have third-party standing to raise issues on behalf of the incarcerated person whose visit or call was affected.
(e)If a visitor’s or caller’s visit or call is interrupted or terminated, and the warden or a court later determines
there was no cause for the interruption or termination, the facility shall provide the visitor or caller with additional visiting and calling time, and shall reimburse the visitor or caller for any expenses associated with the interrupted or terminated call.
(a)At least once a year, each incarcerated person shall be given the opportunity to designate an individual as a “primary support person.”
(b)If an incarcerated person is not placed in a facility administered by the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation that is within 100 miles of the residence of the incarcerated person’s primary support person, as designated by the incarcerated person pursuant to subdivision (a), the primary support person and their minor children shall receive free transportation, transportation vouchers, or transportation reimbursement from an organization, as described in subdivision (c). These services shall be sufficient to visit
the incarcerated person once a month.
(c)(1)The state shall contract with an organization to provide free or subsidized transportation for visits with incarcerated people. The contract shall require the organization to provide free transportation, transportation vouchers, or transportation reimbursement as set forth in subdivision (b). Transportation compensation shall be paid at the state government reimbursement rate.
(2)This organization shall be led by formerly incarcerated or system-impacted people, and shall have at least a one-year history of providing services to or advocating for these people independent of the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation. System-impacted refers to people who have borne financial or other costs of having
relationships with currently or formerly incarcerated people.
(d)The department shall not transfer the incarcerated person in order to avoid transportation costs pursuant to subdivision (c) unless the incarcerated person freely consents.