Bill Text: NJ A4051 | 2022-2023 | Regular Session | Introduced
Bill Title: Prohibits social media websites from selectively suspending candidates for elective office and creates private right of action for users whose political or religious speech has been deleted.
Spectrum: Partisan Bill (Republican 1-0)
Status: (Introduced - Dead) 2022-05-19 - Introduced, Referred to Assembly Consumer Affairs Committee [A4051 Detail]
Download: New_Jersey-2022-A4051-Introduced.html
Sponsored by:
Assemblywoman BETH SAWYER
District 3 (Cumberland, Gloucester and Salem)
SYNOPSIS
Prohibits social media websites from selectively suspending candidates for elective office and creates private right of action for users whose political or religious speech has been deleted
CURRENT VERSION OF TEXT
As introduced.
An Act concerning social media websites and supplementing Title 56 of the Revised Statutes.
Be It Enacted by the Senate and General Assembly of the State of New Jersey:
1. As used in P.L. , c. (C. ) (pending before the Legislature as this bill):
"Algorithm" means a set of computer coded instructions designed to perform a specific task on a social media website.
"Candidate" means an individual seeking election to a public office of the State or any political subdivision thereof, or party office, at any election. "Candidate" includes an individual who runs unopposed, loses an election, withdraws from an election, or raises or spends money, or both, to run for elected office but does not appear on the ballot.
"Consumer Price Index" means the consumer price index for all urban consumers in the New York City and Philadelphia areas as reported by the Department of Labor or any successor index.
"Hate speech" means a word or phrase that an individual finds offensive based on the individual's morality.
"Obscene" means material that a reasonable person, applying contemporary community ethical standards, would find that, taken as a whole, the dominant theme of the material appeals to prurient interests.
"Political speech" means speech relating to the federal, State, or local government, body politic, or public administration as it relates to governmental policymaking and includes, but is not limited to, speech made by a candidate for office and any discussion of social issues. "Political speech" shall not include speech concerning the administration of law or civil aspects of government.
"Religious speech" means a set of unproven answers, truth claims, faith-based assumptions, and assertions that attempt to explain greater questions concerning how the world was created, what constitutes right and wrong actions by humans, and what happens after death.
"Selectively suspend" means the action or practice by a social media website to permanently delete posts or ban a user or to temporarily delete posts or ban a user for more than 60 days.
"Social media website" means any information service, Internet search engine, or access software provider that does business in the State of New Jersey, and provides or enables computer access by multiple users to a computer server, including an Internet website or a social media website, or both, which is a sole proprietorship, partnership, limited liability company, corporation, association, or other legal entity that is organized or operated for the profit or financial benefit of its shareholders or other owners, and that satisfies one or more of the following thresholds:
a. is open to the public;
b. has annual gross revenues in excess of $100 million, as adjusted in January of every odd-numbered year to reflect any increase in the Consumer Price Index; and
c. has at least 100 million monthly users globally.
"User" means a person who has an account on a social media website, regardless of whether the person posts or has posted content or material to the social media website.
2. a. Notwithstanding the provisions of State law, rule, regulation, or order to the contrary, and consistent with federal law, a social media website shall not willfully selectively suspend a candidate who is known by the social media website to be a candidate, beginning on the date the candidate declares an intent to seek election to public office or party office and ending on the date of the election or the date the candidate ceases to be a candidate. A social media website shall provide each user a method by which the user may be identified as a qualified candidate and which provides sufficient information to allow the social media website to confirm the user's qualification as a declared candidate by reviewing the Internet website of the candidate's campaign, the Division of Elections in the Department of State, the New Jersey Election Law Commission, or the Internet website of the local board of elections, as appropriate.
b. A social media website that willfully provides free advertising for a candidate shall inform the candidate of the in-kind contribution and comply with all appropriate provisions of "The New Jersey Campaign Contributions and Expenditures Reporting Act," P.L.1973, c.83 (C.19:44A-1 et seq.). Posts, content, material, and comments by candidates that are shown on the social media website in the same or similar way as other users' posts, content, material, and comments shall not be considered free advertising.
3. Upon a finding of a violation of section 2 of this act by the Election Law Enforcement Commission, in addition to any remedies available pursuant to Title 19 of the Revised Statutes, the commission may assess against a social media website a penalty of $250,000 per day for a violation affecting a candidate for Statewide office and $25,000 per day for a violation affecting a candidate for other offices.
4. a. The owner or operator of a social media website shall be subject to a private right of action by a user if the social media website willfully:
(1) deletes or censors the user's political or religious speech; or
(2) uses an algorithm to disfavor or censor the user's political or religious speech.
b. A user may be awarded all of the following damages:
(1) a minimum of $75,000 per violation of subsection a. of this section;
(2) actual damages;
(3) punitive damages; and
(4) any other form of equitable relief as determined by a court of competent jurisdiction.
c. The prevailing party in a cause of action pursuant to this section may be awarded costs and reasonable attorney fees.
d. In determining damages to be awarded pursuant to subsection b. of this section, a court or jury shall consider whether the owner or operator of a social media website restores from deletion or removes the censoring of a user's speech in a reasonable time.
e. A court or jury shall not consider evidence of a user's alleged hate speech on the social media website as a basis for justification or defense of the social media website's actions pursuant to subsection a. of this section.
5. a. The Attorney General may bring a civil cause of action pursuant to section 4 of P.L. , c. (C. ) (pending before the Legislature as this bill) on behalf of a user whose political or religious speech has been censored, deleted, or disfavored by a social media website.
b. The provisions of subsection a. of this section shall not apply to a social media website that deletes or censors a user's speech or that uses an algorithm to disfavor or censor speech that:
(1) calls for immediate acts of violence;
(2) is obscene or pornographic in nature;
(3) is the result of operational error;
(4) is the result of a court order;
(5) comes from an inauthentic source or involves false impersonation;
(6) entices criminal conduct;
(7) involves the bullying or harassment of a user under the age of 18; or
(8) involves a user censoring another user.
6. This act shall take effect immediately.
STATEMENT
This bill, notwithstanding any contrary provisions of State law, and consistent with federal law, prohibits a social media website from willfully selectively suspending, commonly referred to as "deplatforming," a candidate for office who is known by the social media website to be a candidate, beginning on the date of the qualification and ending on the date of the election or the date the candidate ceases to be a candidate. A social media website is to provide each user of the social media website a method by which the user may be identified as a qualified candidate and which provides sufficient information to allow the social media website to confirm the user's qualification by reviewing the Internet website of the Division of Elections in the Department of State or the Internet website of the local board of elections.
The bill provides that a social media website that willfully provides free advertising for a candidate is to inform the candidate of that in-kind contribution. Posts, content, material, and comments by candidates that are shown on the social media website in the same or similar way as other users' posts, content, material, and comments are not to be considered free advertising.
The bill provides that, upon finding a violation of the provisions of the bill by the Election Law Enforcement Commission, in addition to any remedies available pursuant to State law, the commission may assess against a social media website a penalty of $250,000 per day for a violation affecting a candidate for Statewide office and $25,000 per day for a violation affecting a candidate for other offices.
This bill also creates a private right of action for users of a social media website, as those terms are defined in the bill, whose political or religious speech has been deleted or censored by the social media website or whose political or religious speech has been disfavored or censured by an algorithm used by the social media website. A user may be awarded certain damages provided in the bill.
The bill provides that the prevailing party in a cause of action may be awarded costs and reasonable attorney fees.
The bill provides that a court or jury is required to consider evidence that the owner or operator of a social media website restored from deletion or removed the censoring of a user's speech in a reasonable time when determining damages sought by a user. A court may not consider evidence of a user's alleged hate speech on the social media website as a basis for justification or defense of the social media website's actions.
The bill provides that the Attorney General may bring a civil cause of action on behalf of a user whose political or religious speech has been censored by a social media website under certain circumstances provided in the bill.
