Bill Text: NY S05584 | 2011-2012 | General Assembly | Introduced
Bill Title: Provides a 50% tax credit for new income tax revenue generated by a new employee; provides credit may be taken up to 10 years; provides that the Department of Economic Development must monitor and certify the additional employment for any business which applies for the credit; provides any company taking the credit must maintain employment in the state for twice the number of years as the term of the tax credit; provides the Department of Economic Development shall annually report to the governor and the Legislature on the number and amounts of credits.
Spectrum: Partisan Bill (Democrat 1-0)
Status: (Introduced - Dead) 2012-01-04 - REFERRED TO INVESTIGATIONS AND GOVERNMENT OPERATIONS [S05584 Detail]
Download: New_York-2011-S05584-Introduced.html
S T A T E O F N E W Y O R K ________________________________________________________________________ 5584 2011-2012 Regular Sessions I N S E N A T E June 3, 2011 ___________ Introduced by Sen. PARKER -- read twice and ordered printed, and when printed to be committed to the Committee on Investigations and Govern- ment Operations AN ACT to amend the tax law, in relation to job creation tax credits THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK, REPRESENTED IN SENATE AND ASSEM- BLY, DO ENACT AS FOLLOWS: 1 Section 1. This act shall be known and may be cited as the "Job 2 Creation Tax Credit Act of 2011". 3 S 2. Section 210 of the tax law is amended by adding a new subdivision 4 21-b to read as follows: 5 21-B. JOB CREATION TAX CREDIT. (A) AS USED IN THIS SUBDIVISION, THE 6 FOLLOWING TERMS SHALL HAVE THE FOLLOWING MEANINGS: (1) "FULL-TIME 7 EMPLOYEE" MEANS AN INDIVIDUAL WHO IS EMPLOYED FOR CONSIDERATION FOR AT 8 LEAST THIRTY-FIVE HOURS A WEEK, OR WHO RENDERS ANY OTHER STANDARD OF 9 SERVICE GENERALLY ACCEPTED BY CUSTOM OR SPECIFIED BY CONTRACT AS 10 FULL-TIME EMPLOYMENT. 11 (2) "NEW EMPLOYEE" MEANS A FULL-TIME EMPLOYEE FIRST EMPLOYED BY A 12 TAXPAYER IN THE PROJECT THAT IS THE SUBJECT OF THE TAX CREDIT AUTHORIZED 13 UNDER THIS SUBDIVISION IN THE TAXABLE YEAR IN WHICH THE TAXPAYER SEEKS 14 THE CREDIT. "NEW EMPLOYEE" ALSO MAY INCLUDE AN EMPLOYEE REHIRED OR 15 CALLED BACK FROM LAY-OFF TO WORK IN A NEW FACILITY OR ON A NEW PRODUCT 16 OR SERVICE ESTABLISHED OR PRODUCED BY THE TAXPAYER DURING THE TAXABLE 17 YEAR IN WHICH THE CREDIT IS SOUGHT. "NEW EMPLOYEE" SHALL NOT INCLUDE ANY 18 EMPLOYEE OF THE TAXPAYER WHO WAS PREVIOUSLY EMPLOYED IN THIS STATE BY A 19 RELATED MEMBER OF THE TAXPAYER AND WHOSE EMPLOYMENT WAS SHIFTED TO THE 20 TAXPAYER DURING THE TAXABLE YEAR IN WHICH THE CREDIT IS SOUGHT. IN ADDI- 21 TION, "NEW EMPLOYEE" SHALL NOT INCLUDE A CHILD, GRANDCHILD, PARENT, OR 22 SPOUSE, OTHER THAN A SPOUSE WHO IS LEGALLY SEPARATED FROM THE INDIVID- 23 UAL, OR ANY INDIVIDUAL WHO IS AN EMPLOYEE OF THE TAXPAYER AND WHO HAS A 24 DIRECT OR INDIRECT OWNERSHIP INTEREST OF AT LEAST FIVE PERCENT IN THE 25 PROFITS, CAPITAL, OR VALUE OF THE TAXPAYER. OWNERSHIP INTEREST SHALL BE EXPLANATION--Matter in ITALICS (underscored) is new; matter in brackets [ ] is old law to be omitted. LBD03362-01-1 S. 5584 2 1 DETERMINED IN ACCORDANCE WITH SECTION FIFTEEN HUNDRED SIXTY-THREE OF THE 2 INTERNAL REVENUE CODE AND REGULATIONS PRESCRIBED THEREUNDER. 3 (3) "NEW INCOME TAX REVENUE" MEANS THE TOTAL AMOUNT WITHHELD UNDER 4 THIS CHAPTER BY THE TAXPAYER DURING THE TAXABLE YEAR FROM THE COMPEN- 5 SATION OF NEW EMPLOYEES FOR THE TAXES LEVIED UNDER THIS CHAPTER. 6 (4) "RELATED MEMBER" HAS THE SAME MEANING AS PROVIDED IN THIS CHAPTER. 7 (B) THE JOB CREATION TAX CREDIT AUTHORIZED UNDER THIS SUBDIVISION 8 SHALL BE FOR THE PURPOSE OF FOSTERING JOB CREATION IN THIS STATE. SUCH A 9 GRANT SHALL TAKE THE FORM OF A REFUNDABLE CREDIT ALLOWED AGAINST THE TAX 10 IMPOSED UNDER THIS CHAPTER. THE CREDIT SHALL BE CLAIMED AFTER THE ALLOW- 11 ANCE OF ALL OTHER CREDITS PROVIDED BY THIS CHAPTER. THE AMOUNT OF THE 12 CREDIT SHALL EQUAL THE NEW INCOME TAX REVENUE FOR THE TAXABLE YEAR 13 MULTIPLIED BY FIFTY PERCENT. 14 (C) IN ORDER TO QUALIFY FOR THE CREDIT THE TAXPAYER MUST SUBMIT TO THE 15 DEPARTMENT OF ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT IN THE TAXABLE YEAR FOR WHICH CREDIT 16 IS SOUGHT A FORM PROVIDED BY SUCH DEPARTMENT IN WHICH THE TAXPAYER 17 STATES THE FOLLOWING: 18 (1) THE TAXPAYER'S PROJECT WILL CREATE NEW JOBS IN THIS STATE; 19 (2) THE TAXPAYER'S PROJECT IS ECONOMICALLY SOUND AND WILL BENEFIT THE 20 PEOPLE OF THIS STATE BY INCREASING OPPORTUNITIES FOR EMPLOYMENT AND 21 STRENGTHENING THE ECONOMY OF THIS STATE; 22 (3) RECEIVING THE TAX CREDIT IS A MAJOR FACTOR IN THE TAXPAYER'S DECI- 23 SION TO GO FORWARD WITH THE PROJECT; 24 (4) A DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PROJECT THAT IS THE SUBJECT OF THE 25 AGREEMENT; 26 (5) THE TERM OF THE TAX CREDIT WHICH SHALL NOT EXCEED TEN YEARS, AND 27 THE FIRST TAXABLE YEAR FOR WHICH THE CREDIT MAY BE CLAIMED; 28 (6) THAT THE TAXPAYER SHALL MAINTAIN OPERATIONS AT THE PROJECT 29 LOCATION FOR AT LEAST TWICE THE NUMBER OF YEARS AS THE TERM OF THE TAX 30 CREDIT; 31 (7) THAT FIFTY PERCENT OF THE NEW INCOME TAX REVENUE WILL BE ALLOWED 32 AS THE AMOUNT OF THE CREDIT FOR EACH TAXABLE YEAR; 33 (8) A SPECIFIC METHOD FOR DETERMINING HOW MANY NEW EMPLOYEES ARE 34 EMPLOYED DURING A TAXABLE YEAR; 35 (9) THAT THE TAXPAYER ANNUALLY SHALL REPORT TO THE COMMISSIONER OF 36 ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT THE NUMBER OF NEW EMPLOYEES, THE NEW INCOME TAX 37 REVENUE WITHHELD IN CONNECTION WITH THE NEW EMPLOYEES AND ANY OTHER 38 INFORMATION THE COMMISSIONER OF ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT NEEDS TO PERFORM 39 HIS OR HER DUTIES UNDER THIS SUBDIVISION; AND 40 (10) THAT THE COMMISSIONER OF ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT SHALL ANNUALLY 41 VERIFY THE AMOUNTS REPORTED PURSUANT TO SUBPARAGRAPH NINE OF THIS PARA- 42 GRAPH, AND AFTER DOING SO SHALL ISSUE A CERTIFICATE TO THE TAXPAYER 43 STATING THAT THE AMOUNTS HAVE BEEN VERIFIED. 44 (D) A TAXPAYER CLAIMING A CREDIT UNDER THIS SECTION SHALL SUBMIT TO 45 THE COMMISSIONER A COPY OF THE COMMISSIONER OF ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT'S 46 CERTIFICATE OF VERIFICATION, AS PROVIDED IN SUBPARAGRAPH NINE OF PARA- 47 GRAPH (C) OF THIS SUBDIVISION FOR THE TAXABLE YEAR. 48 (E) THE COMMISSIONER OF ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT, AFTER CONSULTATION WITH 49 THE COMMISSIONER SHALL ADOPT SUCH RULES AND REGULATIONS AS ARE NECESSARY 50 TO IMPLEMENT THIS SUBDIVISION. 51 (F) FOR THE PURPOSES OF THIS SUBDIVISION A TAXPAYER MAY INCLUDE A 52 PARTNERSHIP, A CORPORATION THAT HAS MADE AN ELECTION UNDER SUBCHAPTER S 53 OF CHAPTER ONE OF SUBTITLE A OF THE INTERNAL REVENUE CODE, OR ANY OTHER 54 BUSINESS ENTITY THROUGH WHICH INCOME FLOWS AS A DISTRIBUTIVE SHARE TO 55 ITS OWNERS. A CREDIT RECEIVED UNDER THIS SUBDIVISION BY A PARTNERSHIP, 56 S-CORPORATION, OR OTHER SUCH BUSINESS ENTITY SHALL BE APPORTIONED AMONG S. 5584 3 1 THE PERSONS TO WHOM THE INCOME OR PROFIT OF THE PARTNERSHIP, S-CORPORA- 2 TION, OR OTHER ENTITY IS DISTRIBUTED, IN THE SAME PROPORTIONS AS THOSE 3 IN WHICH THE INCOME OR PROFIT IS DISTRIBUTED. 4 (G) IF THE COMMISSIONER OF ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT DETERMINES THAT A 5 TAXPAYER WHO HAS RECEIVED A CREDIT UNDER THIS SUBDIVISION IS NOT COMPLY- 6 ING WITH THE REQUIREMENT OF SUBPARAGRAPH NINE OF PARAGRAPH (C) OF THIS 7 SUBDIVISION, HE OR SHE SHALL NOTIFY THE COMMISSIONER OF THE NONCOMPLI- 8 ANCE. AFTER RECEIVING SUCH A NOTICE, AND AFTER GIVING THE TAXPAYER AN 9 OPPORTUNITY TO EXPLAIN THE NONCOMPLIANCE, THE COMMISSIONER MAY MAKE AN 10 ASSESSMENT AGAINST THE TAXPAYER UNDER THIS CHAPTER FOR AN AMOUNT NOT 11 EXCEEDING THE SUM OF ANY PREVIOUSLY ALLOWED CREDITS UNDER THIS SUBDIVI- 12 SION. 13 (H) ON OR BEFORE THE THIRTY-FIRST DAY OF MARCH OF EACH YEAR, THE 14 COMMISSIONER OF ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT SHALL SUBMIT A REPORT TO THE GOVER- 15 NOR, THE TEMPORARY PRESIDENT OF THE SENATE, THE SPEAKER OF THE ASSEMBLY 16 AND THE MINORITY LEADERS OF THE SENATE AND ASSEMBLY ON THE TAX CREDIT 17 PROGRAM PROVIDED FOR IN THIS SUBDIVISION. THE REPORT SHALL INCLUDE 18 INFORMATION ON THE NUMBER OF TAXPAYERS RECEIVING TAX CREDITS PURSUANT TO 19 THIS SUBDIVISION DURING THE PRECEDING CALENDAR YEAR, A DESCRIPTION OF 20 THE PROJECTS THAT ARE THE SUBJECT OF THE CREDIT, AND AN UPDATE ON THE 21 STATUS OF PROJECTS FOR WHICH CREDITS WERE ALLOWED DURING THE PRECEDING 22 CALENDAR YEAR. 23 DURING THE FIRST YEAR OF THE TAX CREDIT PROGRAM, THE COMMISSIONER OF 24 ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT IN CONJUNCTION WITH THE DIRECTOR OF BUDGET SHALL 25 CONDUCT AN EVALUATION OF SUCH PROGRAM. THE EVALUATION SHALL INCLUDE 26 ASSESSMENTS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF THE PROGRAM IN CREATING NEW JOBS IN 27 THIS STATE AND OF THE REVENUE IMPACT OF THE PROGRAM. SUCH REPORT MAY 28 ALSO INCLUDE A REVIEW OF THE PRACTICES AND EXPERIENCES OF OTHER STATES 29 WITH SIMILAR PROGRAMS. THE DEPARTMENT OF ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT SHALL 30 SUBMIT A REPORT ON THE EVALUATION TO THE GOVERNOR, THE TEMPORARY PRESI- 31 DENT OF THE SENATE, THE SPEAKER OF THE ASSEMBLY AND THE MINORITY LEADERS 32 OF THE SENATE AND ASSEMBLY ON OR BEFORE JANUARY FIRST, TWO THOUSAND 33 FOURTEEN. 34 S 3. Section 606 of the tax law is amended by adding a new subsection 35 (p-1) to read as follows: 36 (P-1) JOB CREATION TAX CREDIT. (1) AS USED IN THIS SUBSECTION, THE 37 FOLLOWING TERMS SHALL HAVE THE FOLLOWING MEANINGS: 38 (A) "FULL-TIME EMPLOYEE" MEANS AN INDIVIDUAL WHO IS EMPLOYED FOR 39 CONSIDERATION FOR AT LEAST THIRTY-FIVE HOURS A WEEK, OR WHO RENDERS ANY 40 OTHER STANDARD OF SERVICE GENERALLY ACCEPTED BY CUSTOM OR SPECIFIED BY 41 CONTRACT AS FULL-TIME EMPLOYMENT. 42 (B) "NEW EMPLOYEE" MEANS A FULL-TIME EMPLOYEE FIRST EMPLOYED BY A 43 TAXPAYER IN THE PROJECT THAT IS THE SUBJECT OF THE TAX CREDIT AUTHORIZED 44 UNDER THIS SUBSECTION IN THE TAXABLE YEAR IN WHICH THE TAXPAYER SEEKS 45 THE CREDIT. "NEW EMPLOYEE" ALSO MAY INCLUDE AN EMPLOYEE REHIRED OR 46 CALLED BACK FROM LAY-OFF TO WORK IN A NEW FACILITY OR ON A NEW PRODUCT 47 OR SERVICE ESTABLISHED OR PRODUCED BY THE TAXPAYER DURING THE TAXABLE 48 YEAR IN WHICH THE CREDIT IS SOUGHT. "NEW EMPLOYEE" SHALL NOT INCLUDE ANY 49 EMPLOYEE OF THE TAXPAYER WHO WAS PREVIOUSLY EMPLOYED IN THIS STATE BY A 50 RELATED MEMBER OF THE TAXPAYER AND WHOSE EMPLOYMENT WAS SHIFTED TO THE 51 TAXPAYER DURING THE TAXABLE YEAR IN WHICH THE CREDIT IS SOUGHT. IN ADDI- 52 TION, "NEW EMPLOYEE" SHALL NOT INCLUDE A CHILD, GRANDCHILD, PARENT, OR 53 SPOUSE, OTHER THAN A SPOUSE WHO IS LEGALLY SEPARATED FROM THE INDIVID- 54 UAL, OR ANY INDIVIDUAL WHO IS AN EMPLOYEE OF THE TAXPAYER AND WHO HAS A 55 DIRECT OR INDIRECT OWNERSHIP INTEREST OF AT LEAST FIVE PERCENT IN THE 56 PROFITS, CAPITAL, OR VALUE OF THE TAXPAYER. OWNERSHIP INTEREST SHALL BE S. 5584 4 1 DETERMINED IN ACCORDANCE WITH SECTION FIFTEEN HUNDRED SIXTY-THREE OF THE 2 INTERNAL REVENUE CODE AND REGULATIONS PRESCRIBED THEREUNDER. 3 (C) "NEW INCOME TAX REVENUE" MEANS THE TOTAL AMOUNT WITHHELD UNDER 4 THIS CHAPTER BY THE TAXPAYER DURING THE TAXABLE YEAR FROM THE COMPEN- 5 SATION OF NEW EMPLOYEES FOR THE TAX LEVIES UNDER THIS CHAPTER. 6 (D) "RELATED MEMBER" HAS THE SAME MEANING AS PROVIDED IN THIS CHAPTER. 7 (2) THE JOB CREATION TAX CREDIT AUTHORIZED UNDER THIS SUBSECTION SHALL 8 BE FOR THE PURPOSE OF FOSTERING JOB CREATION IN THIS STATE. SUCH A 9 GRANT SHALL TAKE THE FORM OF A REFUNDABLE CREDIT ALLOWED AGAINST THE TAX 10 IMPOSED UNDER THIS CHAPTER. THE CREDIT SHALL BE CLAIMED AFTER THE ALLOW- 11 ANCE OF ALL OTHER CREDITS PROVIDED BY THIS CHAPTER. THE AMOUNT OF THE 12 CREDIT SHALL EQUAL THE NEW INCOME TAX REVENUE FOR THE TAXABLE YEAR 13 MULTIPLIED BY FIFTY PERCENT. 14 (3) IN ORDER TO QUALIFY FOR THE CREDIT THE TAXPAYER MUST SUBMIT TO THE 15 DEPARTMENT OF ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT IN THE TAXABLE YEAR FOR WHICH CREDIT 16 IS SOUGHT A FORM PROVIDED BY SUCH DEPARTMENT IN WHICH THE TAXPAYER 17 STATES THE FOLLOWING: 18 (A) THE TAXPAYER'S PROJECT WILL CREATE NEW JOBS IN THIS STATE; 19 (B) THE TAXPAYER'S PROJECT IS ECONOMICALLY SOUND AND WILL BENEFIT THE 20 PEOPLE OF THIS STATE BY INCREASING OPPORTUNITIES FOR EMPLOYMENT AND 21 STRENGTHENING THE ECONOMY OF THIS STATE; 22 (C) RECEIVING THE TAX CREDIT IS A MAJOR FACTOR IN THE TAXPAYER'S DECI- 23 SION TO GO FORWARD WITH THE PROJECT; 24 (D) A DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PROJECT THAT IS THE SUBJECT OF THE 25 AGREEMENT; 26 (E) THE TERM OF THE TAX CREDIT WHICH SHALL NOT EXCEED TEN YEARS, AND 27 THE FIRST TAXABLE YEAR FOR WHICH THE CREDIT MAY BE CLAIMED; 28 (F) THAT THE TAXPAYER SHALL MAINTAIN OPERATIONS AT THE PROJECT 29 LOCATION FOR AT LEAST TWICE THE NUMBER OF YEARS AS THE TERM OF THE TAX 30 CREDIT; 31 (G) THAT FIFTY PERCENT OF THE NEW INCOME TAX REVENUE WILL BE ALLOWED 32 AS THE AMOUNT OF THE CREDIT FOR EACH TAXABLE YEAR; 33 (H) A SPECIFIC METHOD FOR DETERMINING HOW MANY NEW EMPLOYEES ARE 34 EMPLOYED DURING A TAXABLE YEAR; 35 (I) THAT THE TAXPAYER ANNUALLY SHALL REPORT TO THE COMMISSIONER OF 36 ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT THE NUMBER OF NEW EMPLOYEES, THE NEW INCOME TAX 37 REVENUE WITHHELD IN CONNECTION WITH THE NEW EMPLOYEES AND ANY OTHER 38 INFORMATION THE COMMISSIONER OF ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT NEEDS TO PERFORM 39 HIS OR HER DUTIES UNDER THIS SUBSECTION; AND 40 (J) THAT THE COMMISSIONER OF ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT SHALL ANNUALLY VERI- 41 FY THE AMOUNTS REPORTED PURSUANT TO SUBPARAGRAPH (I) OF THIS PARAGRAPH, 42 AND AFTER DOING SO SHALL ISSUE A CERTIFICATE TO THE TAXPAYER STATING 43 THAT THE AMOUNTS HAVE BEEN VERIFIED. 44 (4) A TAXPAYER CLAIMING A CREDIT UNDER THIS SUBSECTION SHALL SUBMIT TO 45 THE COMMISSIONER A COPY OF THE COMMISSIONER OF ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT'S 46 CERTIFICATE OF VERIFICATION AS PROVIDED IN SUBPARAGRAPH (I) OF PARAGRAPH 47 THREE OF THIS SUBSECTION FOR THE TAXABLE YEAR. 48 (5) THE COMMISSIONER OF ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT, AFTER CONSULTATION WITH 49 THE COMMISSIONER SHALL ADOPT SUCH RULES AND REGULATIONS AS ARE NECESSARY 50 TO IMPLEMENT THIS SUBSECTION. 51 (6) FOR THE PURPOSES OF THIS SUBSECTION A TAXPAYER MAY INCLUDE A PART- 52 NERSHIP, A CORPORATION THAT HAS MADE AN ELECTION UNDER SUBCHAPTER S OF 53 CHAPTER ONE OF SUBTITLE A OF THE INTERNAL REVENUE CODE, OR ANY OTHER 54 BUSINESS ENTITY THROUGH WHICH INCOME FLOWS AS A DISTRIBUTIVE SHARE TO 55 ITS OWNERS. A CREDIT RECEIVED UNDER THIS SUBSECTION BY A PARTNERSHIP, 56 S-CORPORATION, OR OTHER SUCH BUSINESS ENTITY SHALL BE APPORTIONED AMONG S. 5584 5 1 THE PERSONS TO WHOM THE INCOME OR PROFIT OF THE PARTNERSHIP, S-CORPORA- 2 TION, OR OTHER ENTITY IS DISTRIBUTED, IN THE SAME PROPORTIONS AS THOSE 3 IN WHICH THE INCOME OR PROFIT IS DISTRIBUTED. 4 (7) IF THE COMMISSIONER OF ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT DETERMINES THAT A 5 TAXPAYER WHO HAS RECEIVED A CREDIT UNDER THIS SUBSECTION IS NOT COMPLY- 6 ING WITH THE REQUIREMENT OF SUBPARAGRAPH (I) OF PARAGRAPH THREE OF THIS 7 SUBSECTION, HE OR SHE SHALL NOTIFY THE COMMISSIONER OF THE NONCOMPLI- 8 ANCE. AFTER RECEIVING SUCH A NOTICE, AND AFTER GIVING THE TAXPAYER AN 9 OPPORTUNITY TO EXPLAIN THE NONCOMPLIANCE, THE COMMISSIONER MAY MAKE AN 10 ASSESSMENT AGAINST THE TAXPAYER UNDER THIS CHAPTER FOR AN AMOUNT NOT 11 EXCEEDING THE SUM OF ANY PREVIOUSLY ALLOWED CREDITS UNDER THIS 12 SUBSECTION. 13 (8) ON OR BEFORE THE THIRTY-FIRST DAY OF MARCH OF EACH YEAR, THE 14 COMMISSIONER OF ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT SHALL SUBMIT A REPORT TO THE GOVER- 15 NOR, THE TEMPORARY PRESIDENT OF THE SENATE, THE SPEAKER OF THE ASSEMBLY 16 AND THE MINORITY LEADERS OF THE SENATE AND ASSEMBLY ON THE TAX CREDIT 17 PROGRAM PROVIDED FOR IN THIS SUBSECTION. THE REPORT SHALL INCLUDE INFOR- 18 MATION ON THE NUMBER OF TAXPAYERS RECEIVING TAX CREDITS PURSUANT TO THIS 19 SUBSECTION DURING THE PRECEDING CALENDAR YEAR, A DESCRIPTION OF THE 20 PROJECTS THAT ARE THE SUBJECT OF THE CREDIT, AND AN UPDATE ON THE STATUS 21 OF PROJECTS FOR WHICH CREDITS WERE ALLOWED DURING THE PRECEDING CALENDAR 22 YEAR. 23 DURING THE FIRST YEAR OF THE TAX CREDIT PROGRAM, THE COMMISSIONER OF 24 ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT IN CONJUNCTION WITH THE DIRECTOR OF BUDGET SHALL 25 CONDUCT AN EVALUATION OF SUCH PROGRAM. THE EVALUATION SHALL INCLUDE 26 ASSESSMENTS OF THE EFFECTIVENESS OF THE PROGRAM IN CREATING NEW JOBS IN 27 THIS STATE AND OF THE REVENUE IMPACT OF THE PROGRAM. SUCH REPORT MAY 28 ALSO INCLUDE A REVIEW OF THE PRACTICES AND EXPERIENCES OF OTHER STATES 29 WITH SIMILAR PROGRAMS. THE DEPARTMENT OF ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT SHALL 30 SUBMIT A REPORT ON THE EVALUATION TO THE GOVERNOR, THE TEMPORARY PRESI- 31 DENT OF THE SENATE, THE SPEAKER OF THE ASSEMBLY AND THE MINORITY LEADERS 32 OF THE SENATE AND ASSEMBLY ON OR BEFORE JANUARY FIRST, TWO THOUSAND 33 SIXTEEN. 34 S 4. This act shall take effect immediately and shall apply to taxable 35 years commencing on and after April 1, 2011.